| | | Monmouth wins toss, will defer and kick off, defeding the South Goal. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg30 | MC ball on MC30. |
| | | Matt Batton kickoff 47 yards to the WARTBURG23, Spencer Rowell return 6 yards to the WARTBURG29 (Zach Duncan). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg29 | Reese Thompson rush for 5 yards to the WARTBURG34 (Adam Hoste). |
| Wartburg | 2-5 | at Wartburg34 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete (Cory Bishop). |
| Wartburg | 3-5 | at Wartburg34 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to DJ Looft for 4 yards to the WARTBURG38 (Ryan Hix). |
| Wartburg | 4-1 | at Wartburg38 | Robby Salmon punt 56 yards to the MC6, Mike Blodgett return 12 yards to the MC18 (Logan Hansen), PENALTY MC illegal block 10 yards to the MC8, 1st and 10, MC ball on MC8. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:35 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc08 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 13:25. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc08 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete. |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Mc08 | Trey Yocum rush for 16 yards to the MC24, 1ST DOWN MC (Mark Lueschow). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc24 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Mike Blodgett for 1 yard to the MC25 (Mark Lueschow;Riley Anderson). |
| Mc | 2-9 | at Mc25 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Michael Davis for 6 yards to the MC31 (Jason Shupp). |
| Mc | 3-3 | at Mc31 | Alex Tanney pass intercepted by Garrett McGrane at the MC36, Garrett McGrane return 36 yards to the MC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:13, Marcu Williams kick attempt good. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 23 yards, TOP 01:12 |
| | | Wartburg College 7, Monmouth College 0 |
| Wartburg | 1-G | at Wartburg30 | PENALTY MC personal foul 15 yards to the WARTBURG45. |
| Wartburg | 1-G | at Wartburg45 | WARTBURG ball on WARTBURG45. |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 55 yards to the MC0, Mike Blodgett return 50 yards to the 50 yardline (Mark Lueschow). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc50 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 12:13. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc50 | Trey Yocum rush for 1 yard to the WARTBURG49 (Mark Lueschow). |
| Mc | 2-9 | at Wartburg49 | Trey Yocum rush for no gain to the WARTBURG49 (Ross Naylor). |
| Mc | 3-9 | at Wartburg49 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Mike Blodgett for 16 yards to the WARTBURG33, 1ST DOWN MC (Garrett McGrane). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg33 | Trey Yocum rush for 23 yards to the WARTBURG10, 1ST DOWN MC (Josh VanDenHul). |
| Mc | 1-G | at Wartburg10 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Mike Blodgett for 10 yards to the WARTBURG0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:31, Matt Batton kick attempt good. |
| | | Wartburg College 7, Monmouth College 7 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 50 yards, TOP 01:42 |
| | | Matt Batton kickoff 65 yards to the WARTBURG5, Josh VanDenHul return 18 yards to the WARTBURG23 (Nick Law). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg23 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 10:31. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg23 | Brandon Sims rush for 20 yards to the WARTBURG43, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Shane Reschke). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg43 | Brandon Sims rush for 2 yards to the WARTBURG45. |
| Wartburg | 2-8 | at Wartburg45 | PENALTY MC offside 5 yards to the 50 yardline. |
| Wartburg | 2-3 | at Wartburg50 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete. |
| Wartburg | 3-3 | at Wartburg50 | Brandon Sims rush for 6 yards to the MC44, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Ryan Hix;Adam Hoste). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc44 | Brandon Sims rush for loss of 1 yard to the MC45 (Rod Ojong). |
| Wartburg | 2-11 | at Mc45 | Brandon Sims rush for loss of 1 yard to the MC46 (Myles Davis). |
| Wartburg | 3-12 | at Mc46 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Logan Ruffridge for 16 yards to the MC30, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Ryan Flannigan). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc30 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Levi Helbing. |
| Wartburg | 2-10 | at Mc30 | Brandon Sims rush for 3 yards to the MC27 (Cory Bishop;Adam Hoste). |
| Wartburg | 3-7 | at Mc27 | PENALTY WARTBURG false start 5 yards to the MC32. |
| Wartburg | 3-12 | at Mc32 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbing for 31 yards to the MC1, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG. |
| Wartburg | 1-G | at Mc01 | Reese Thompson rush for no gain to the MC1 (Adam Hoste;Rod Ojong). |
| Wartburg | 2-G | at Mc01 | Dan Stiefel rush for 1 yard to the MC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:53, Marcu Williams kick attempt good. |
| | | Wartburg College 14, Monmouth College 7 |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 77 yards, TOP 05:38 |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 42 yards to the MC28, Evan Banks return 18 yards to the MC46 (Jason Shupp). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc46 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 04:53. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc46 | Alex Tanney sacked for loss of 11 yards to the MC35 (Logan Hansen). |
| Mc | 2-21 | at Mc35 | Stefan Flynn rush for 2 yards to the MC37 (Ben Bentil;Ryan Billings). |
| Mc | 3-19 | at Mc37 | Alex Tanney pass complete to David Milroy for 23 yards to the WARTBURG40, fumble forced by Garrett McGrane, fumble by David Milroy recovered by MC David Milroy at WARTBURG38, 1ST DOWN MC. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg38 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Michael Davis for 7 yards to the WARTBURG31 (Ben Bentil). |
| Mc | 2-3 | at Wartburg31 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete to Gar. Youngren. |
| Mc | 3-3 | at Wartburg31 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Mike Blodgett for 9 yards to the WARTBURG22, 1ST DOWN MC (David Brooks). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg22 | Trey Yocum rush for 2 yards to the WARTBURG20 (Chad Crawford). |
| Mc | 2-8 | at Wartburg20 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete to Michael Davis, dropped pass. |
| Mc | 3-8 | at Wartburg20 | Nick Law rush for 20 yards to the WARTBURG0, 1ST DOWN MC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:59, Matt Batton kick attempt good. |
| | | Wartburg College 14, Monmouth College 14 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 54 yards, TOP 02:54 |
| | | Matt Batton kickoff 65 yards to the WARTBURG5, Josh VanDenHul return 11 yards to the WARTBURG16 (M. Lafferty), PENALTY WARTBURG illegal block 10 yards to the WARTBURG6, 1st and 10, WARTBURG ball on WARTBURG6. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg06 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 01:59. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg06 | Brandon Sims rush for 4 yards to the WARTBURG10 (Preston Lumzy). |
| Wartburg | 2-6 | at Wartburg10 | Brandon Sims rush for loss of 1 yard to the WARTBURG9 (Sam Hoster). |
| Wartburg | 3-7 | at Wartburg09 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Levi Helbing. |
| Wartburg | 4-7 | at Wartburg09 | PENALTY MC offside 5 yards to the WARTBURG14. |
| Wartburg | 4-2 | at Wartburg14 | Robby Salmon punt 43 yards to the MC43, Mike Blodgett return 16 yards to the WARTBURG41 (Martin Hyatte). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg41 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 01:59. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg41 | Stefan Flynn rush for 2 yards to the WARTBURG39 (Ryan Billings). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 2 yards, TOP 02:05 |
| | | Wartburg College 14, Monmouth College 14 |
| Mc | 2-8 | at Wartburg39 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mc | 2-8 | at Wartburg39 | Brik Wedekind rush for loss of 3 yards to the WARTBURG42, fumble by Brik Wedekind recovered by WARTBURG Ben Bentil at WARTBURG39. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 2 yards, TOP 02:05 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg39 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 14:54. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg39 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Levi Helbing. |
| Wartburg | 2-10 | at Wartburg39 | Reese Thompson rush for 11 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Ryan Hix). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg50 | Reese Thompson rush for no gain to the 50 yardline (Ryan Hix;Adam Hoste). |
| Wartburg | 2-10 | at Wartburg50 | Dan Stiefel sacked for loss of 5 yards to the WARTBURG45 (Mike Kettmann). |
| Wartburg | 3-15 | at Wartburg45 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Levi Helbing. |
| Wartburg | 4-15 | at Wartburg45 | Robby Salmon punt 36 yards to the MC19, fair catch by Mike Blodgett. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 6 yards, TOP 02:21 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc19 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 12:33. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc19 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete to Trey Yocum (Martin Hyatte). |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Mc19 | Trey Yocum rush for 5 yards to the MC24 (David Brooks). |
| Mc | 3-5 | at Mc24 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete to Austin Peterson. |
| Mc | 4-5 | at Mc24 | Brik Wedekind punt 44 yards to the WARTBURG32, Josh VanDenHul return 5 yards to the WARTBURG37 (David Milroy;Adam Hoste). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 00:58 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg37 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 11:35. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg37 | Reese Thompson rush for loss of 6 yards to the WARTBURG31 (Preston Lumzy). |
| Wartburg | 2-16 | at Wartburg31 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Reese Thompson for 1 yard to the WARTBURG32 (Mike Kettmann). |
| Wartburg | 3-15 | at Wartburg32 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to DJ Looft for 5 yards to the WARTBURG37 (Shane Reschke;Ryan Flannigan). |
| Wartburg | 4-10 | at Wartburg37 | Robby Salmon punt 53 yards to the MC10, Mike Blodgett return 20 yards to the MC30 (Justin Denner). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 02:22 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc30 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 09:13. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc30 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete to Mike Blodgett (David Brooks). |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Mc30 | Trey Yocum rush for 2 yards to the MC32 (Chad Crawford;Mark Lueschow). |
| Mc | 3-8 | at Mc32 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Michael Davis for 11 yards to the MC43, 1ST DOWN MC (Ryan Billings). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc43 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Michael Davis for 5 yards to the MC48 (Garrett McGrane). |
| Mc | 2-5 | at Mc48 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Mike Blodgett for 36 yards to the WARTBURG16, 1ST DOWN MC (Josh VanDenHul). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg16 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete (Ross Naylor). |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Wartburg16 | Trey Yocum rush for 6 yards to the WARTBURG10 (Riley Anderson). |
| Mc | 3-4 | at Wartburg10 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete to Stefan Flynn. |
| Mc | 4-4 | at Wartburg10 | Matt Batton field goal attempt from 26 GOOD, clock 06:22. |
| | | Monmouth College 17, Wartburg College 14 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 60 yards, TOP 02:51 |
| | | Matt Batton kickoff 68 yards to the WARTBURG2, Spence Capitani return 17 yards to the WARTBURG19 (Zach Duncan;Nick Law). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg19 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 06:22. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg19 | Dan Stiefel rush for loss of 2 yards to the WARTBURG17, fumble by Dan Stiefel recovered by WARTBURG Dan Stiefel at WARTBURG17. |
| Wartburg | 2-12 | at Wartburg17 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete. |
| Wartburg | 3-12 | at Wartburg17 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete (Preston Lumzy). |
| Wartburg | 4-12 | at Wartburg17 | Robby Salmon punt 41 yards to the MC42, fair catch by Mike Blodgett. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 01:12 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc42 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 05:10. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc42 | Stefan Flynn rush for 9 yards to the WARTBURG49 (David Brooks;Ryan Billings). |
| Mc | 2-1 | at Wartburg49 | Stefan Flynn rush for 4 yards to the WARTBURG45, 1ST DOWN MC (Logan Hansen). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg45 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete to Michael Davis, dropped pass. |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Wartburg45 | Trey Yocum rush for 24 yards to the WARTBURG21, 1ST DOWN MC (Garrett McGrane). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg21 | PENALTY MC false start 5 yards to the WARTBURG26. |
| Mc | 1-15 | at Wartburg26 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Mike Blodgett for 9 yards to the WARTBURG17 (David Brooks). |
| Mc | 2-6 | at Wartburg17 | Stefan Flynn rush for loss of 2 yards to the WARTBURG19 (Jason Shupp). |
| Mc | 3-8 | at Wartburg19 | PENALTY MC delay of game 5 yards to the WARTBURG24. |
| Mc | 3-13 | at Wartburg24 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Gar. Youngren for 12 yards to the WARTBURG12. |
| Mc | 4-1 | at Wartburg12 | Matt Batton field goal attempt from 29 GOOD, clock 02:15. |
| | | Monmouth College 20, Wartburg College 14 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 46 yards, TOP 02:55 |
| | | Matt Batton kickoff 59 yards to the WARTBURG11, Spence Capitani return 19 yards to the WARTBURG30 (Shane Reschke). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg30 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 02:15. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg30 | Reese Thompson rush for loss of 1 yard to the WARTBURG29, fumble forced by Ryan Hix, fumble by Reese Thompson recovered by WARTBURG Reese Thompson at WARTBURG29. |
| Wartburg | 2-11 | at Wartburg29 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete. |
| Wartburg | 3-11 | at Wartburg29 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to DJ Looft for 6 yards to the WARTBURG35 (Andre Taylor). |
| Wartburg | 4-5 | at Wartburg35 | Timeout Monmouth College, clock 01:23. |
| Wartburg | 4-5 | at Wartburg35 | Robby Salmon punt 48 yards to the MC17, Nick Law return 26 yards to the MC43 (Justin Denner;Robby Salmon). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:06 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc43 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 01:09. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc43 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Michael Davis for 8 yards to the WARTBURG49 (Jason Shupp). |
| Mc | 2-2 | at Wartburg49 | Alex Tanney sacked for loss of 3 yards to the MC48 (Jason Shupp), PENALTY MC holding 5 yards to the MC43. |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Mc43 | 3rd and 11. |
| Mc | 3-11 | at Mc43 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete to Gar. Youngren. |
| Mc | 4-11 | at Mc43 | Brik Wedekind punt 37 yards to the WARTBURG20, fair catch by Josh VanDenHul. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:55 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg20 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 00:14. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg20 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbing for 36 yards to the MC44, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG, out-of-bounds. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc44 | Timeout Wartburg College, clock 00:06. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc44 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Bryan Woods, dropped pass. |
| Wartburg | 2-10 | at Mc44 | Dan Stiefel pass intercepted by Andre Taylor at the MC0, Andre Taylor return 0 yards to the MC0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 36 yards, TOP 00:14 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc20 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 00:00. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc20 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Monmouth College 20, Wartburg College 14 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc20 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, WARTBURG ball on WARTBURG30. |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 64 yards to the MC6, Nick Law return 51 yards to the WARTBURG43 (Garrett McGrane). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg43 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 15:00. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg43 | Trey Yocum rush for 3 yards to the WARTBURG40 (Logan Hansen). |
| Mc | 2-7 | at Wartburg40 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Trey Yocum for 15 yards to the WARTBURG25, 1ST DOWN MC (David Brooks). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg25 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete to Austin Peterson. |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Wartburg25 | Trey Yocum rush for 3 yards to the WARTBURG22 (Jason Shupp;Ben Bentil). |
| Mc | 3-7 | at Wartburg22 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Mike Blodgett for 13 yards to the WARTBURG9, fumble forced by Mark Lueschow, fumble by Mike Blodgett recovered by WARTBURG Mark Lueschow at WARTBURG9. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 34 yards, TOP 01:29 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg09 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 13:31. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg09 | Brandon Sims rush for 3 yards to the WARTBURG12 (Rod Ojong). |
| Wartburg | 2-7 | at Wartburg12 | Brandon Sims rush for 6 yards to the WARTBURG18 (Nate Van Metre). |
| Wartburg | 3-1 | at Wartburg18 | Brandon Sims rush for 2 yards to the WARTBURG20, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Adam Hoste). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg20 | Brandon Sims rush for loss of 1 yard to the WARTBURG19 (Myles Davis). |
| Wartburg | 2-11 | at Wartburg19 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Alce Smith for 81 yards to the MC0, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:59, Marcu Williams kick attempt good. |
| | | Wartburg College 21, Monmouth College 20 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 91 yards, TOP 02:32 |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 57 yards to the MC13, Nick Law return 18 yards to the MC31 (Riley Anderson). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc31 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 10:59. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc31 | Trey Yocum rush for 4 yards to the MC35 (Justin Denner). |
| Mc | 2-6 | at Mc35 | Trey Yocum rush for 4 yards to the MC39 (Daylon Bacot;Matt Tschetter). |
| Mc | 3-2 | at Mc39 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Austin Peterson for 6 yards to the MC45, 1ST DOWN MC, out-of-bounds. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc45 | Trey Yocum rush for 1 yard to the MC46 (Jason Shupp;Riley Anderson). |
| Mc | 2-9 | at Mc46 | Trey Yocum rush for 8 yards to the WARTBURG46 (Matt Tschetter). |
| Mc | 3-1 | at Wartburg46 | Trey Yocum rush for loss of 1 yard to the WARTBURG47 (Jason Shupp;Garrett McGrane). |
| Mc | 4-2 | at Wartburg47 | Brik Wedekind punt 42 yards to the WARTBURG5, downed. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 22 yards, TOP 02:56 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg05 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 08:03. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg05 | Reese Thompson rush for 5 yards to the WARTBURG10 (Rod Ojong). |
| Wartburg | 2-5 | at Wartburg10 | Reese Thompson rush for 5 yards to the WARTBURG15, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Adam Hoste). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg15 | Reese Thompson rush for 3 yards to the WARTBURG18 (Rod Ojong). |
| Wartburg | 2-7 | at Wartburg18 | Reese Thompson rush for 2 yards to the WARTBURG20 (Myles Davis;Rod Ojong). |
| Wartburg | 3-5 | at Wartburg20 | Reese Thompson rush for 8 yards to the WARTBURG28, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Preston Lumzy;Rod Ojong). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg28 | Reese Thompson rush for 1 yard to the WARTBURG29, fumble forced by Mike Kettmann, fumble by Reese Thompson recovered by MC Nate Van Metre at WARTBURG29. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 24 yards, TOP 02:52 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg29 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 05:11. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg29 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Stefan Flynn for 3 yards to the WARTBURG26 (Jared Wauters), PENALTY MC holding 10 yards to the WARTBURG36. |
| Mc | 1-17 | at Wartburg36 | 1st and 17. |
| Mc | 1-17 | at Wartburg36 | Stefan Flynn rush for 5 yards to the WARTBURG31 (Jason Shupp;Martin Hyatte). |
| Mc | 2-12 | at Wartburg31 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Mike Blodgett for 4 yards to the WARTBURG27 (Riley Anderson). |
| Mc | 3-8 | at Wartburg27 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Mike Blodgett for no gain to the WARTBURG27 (Garrett McGrane). |
| Mc | 4-8 | at Wartburg27 | Matt Batton field goal attempt from 44 MISSED - wide left, spot at WARTBURG27, clock 02:50. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 2 yards, TOP 02:21 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg27 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 02:50. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg27 | Brandon Sims rush for 2 yards to the WARTBURG29 (Rod Ojong). |
| Wartburg | 2-8 | at Wartburg29 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbing for 70 yards to the MC1, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Andre Taylor). |
| Wartburg | 1-G | at Mc01 | Dan Stiefel rush for no gain to the MC1 (Mike Kettmann). |
| Wartburg | 2-G | at Mc01 | Dan Stiefel rush for no gain to the MC1 (Mike Kettmann;Adam Hoste). |
| Wartburg | 3-G | at Mc01 | Brandon Sims rush for 1 yard to the MC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:46, Marcu Williams kick attempt good. |
| | | Wartburg College 28, Monmouth College 20 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 73 yards, TOP 02:04 |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 59 yards to the MC11, Luther McDowell return 8 yards to the MC19 (Mark Lueschow). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc19 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 00:46. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc19 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Mike Blodgett for 4 yards to the MC23 (Mark Lueschow). |
| Mc | 2-6 | at Mc23 | Stefan Flynn rush for 9 yards to the MC32, 1ST DOWN MC (Jared Wauters). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc32 | Stefan Flynn rush for 2 yards to the MC34 (Ross Naylor;Chad Crawford). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 15 yards, TOP 02:01 |
| | | Wartburg College 28, Monmouth College 20 |
| Mc | 2-8 | at Mc34 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mc | 2-8 | at Mc34 | Trey Yocum rush for 1 yard to the MC35 (Nathan Jones;Jason Shupp). |
| Mc | 3-7 | at Mc35 | PENALTY MC false start 5 yards to the MC30. |
| Mc | 3-12 | at Mc30 | Alex Tanney sacked for loss of 3 yards to the MC27 (Ross Naylor;Matt Tschetter). |
| Mc | 4-15 | at Mc27 | Brik Wedekind punt 47 yards to the WARTBURG26, Josh VanDenHul return 5 yards to the WARTBURG31 (Jake Willis;Kevin Turner). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 8 yards, TOP 02:01 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg31 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 13:45. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg31 | Brandon Sims rush for 12 yards to the WARTBURG43, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Shane Reschke;Erik Weber). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg43 | Timeout Wartburg College, clock 13:09. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg43 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Alce Smith. |
| Wartburg | 2-10 | at Wartburg43 | Brandon Sims rush for 6 yards to the WARTBURG49 (Ryan Flannigan;Erik Weber). |
| Wartburg | 3-4 | at Wartburg49 | PENALTY WARTBURG false start 5 yards to the WARTBURG44. |
| Wartburg | 3-9 | at Wartburg44 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to DJ Looft for 31 yards to the MC25, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Erik Weber). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc25 | Brandon Sims rush for loss of 2 yards to the MC27 (Rod Ojong), PENALTY WARTBURG holding 10 yards to the MC37. |
| Wartburg | 1-22 | at Mc37 | 1st and 22. |
| Wartburg | 1-22 | at Mc37 | Brandon Sims rush for 2 yards to the MC35 (Shane Reschke). |
| Wartburg | 2-20 | at Mc35 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Alce Smith, PENALTY MC holding 10 yards to the MC25, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG, NO PLAY. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc25 | Brandon Sims rush for 2 yards to the MC23 (Preston Lumzy). |
| Wartburg | 2-8 | at Mc23 | Reese Thompson rush for 6 yards to the MC17 (Preston Lumzy). |
| Wartburg | 3-2 | at Mc17 | Reese Thompson rush for 2 yards to the MC15, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Cory Bishop). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc15 | Reese Thompson rush for 2 yards to the MC13 (Mike Kettmann). |
| Wartburg | 2-8 | at Mc13 | Reese Thompson rush for 1 yard to the MC12 (Mike Kettmann). |
| Wartburg | 3-7 | at Mc12 | Reese Thompson rush for 2 yards to the MC10, fumble forced by Preston Lumzy, fumble by Reese Thompson recovered by MC Rod Ojong at MC9. |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 60 yards, TOP 06:06 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc09 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 07:39. |
| | | Weather Delay with 7:39 left in 4th quarter. |
| | | Game resumed after an approximately three hour weather delay. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc09 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Michael Davis for 2 yards to the MC11 (Garrett McGrane). |
| Mc | 2-8 | at Mc11 | Trey Yocum rush for 1 yard to the MC12 (Ben Bentil). |
| Mc | 3-7 | at Mc12 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete. |
| Mc | 4-7 | at Mc12 | Brik Wedekind punt 35 yards to the MC47, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:12 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc47 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 06:27. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc47 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for 1 yard to the MC46 (Mike Kettmann). |
| Wartburg | 2-9 | at Mc46 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for 8 yards to the MC38. |
| Wartburg | 3-1 | at Mc38 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for 2 yards to the MC36, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Rod Ojong;Myles Davis). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc36 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for no gain to the MC36 (Sam Hoster). |
| Wartburg | 2-10 | at Mc36 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for 6 yards to the MC30 (Mike Kettmann;Wes Kindurys). |
| Wartburg | 3-4 | at Mc30 | Brandon Sims rush for loss of 2 yards to the MC32, fumble by Brandon Sims recovered by WARTBURG Brandon Sims at MC33. |
| Wartburg | 4-7 | at Mc33 | Timeout Wartburg College, clock 02:15. |
| Wartburg | 4-7 | at Mc33 | Logan Ruffridge rush for 16 yards to the MC17, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Ryan Flannigan). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc17 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for 17 yards to the MC0, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:36, Marcu Williams kick attempt good. |
| | | Wartburg College 35, Monmouth College 20 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 47 yards, TOP 04:51 |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 56 yards to the MC14, Nick Law return 22 yards to the MC36 (Conn Dahlstrom). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc36 | MONMOUTH COLLEGE drive start at 01:36. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc36 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete to Austin Peterson. |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Mc36 | Alex Tanney pass incomplete to Gar. Youngren, dropped pass. |
| Mc | 3-10 | at Mc36 | Alex Tanney sacked for loss of 11 yards to the MC25 (Matt Tschetter;Jason Shupp). |
| Mc | 4-21 | at Mc25 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Spencer Brown for 50 yards to the WARTBURG25, 1ST DOWN MC (Jared Wauters). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg25 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Spencer Brown for 14 yards to the WARTBURG11, 1ST DOWN MC (Jason Shupp). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg11 | Timeout Monmouth College, clock 00:24. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Wartburg11 | Alex Tanney pass complete to Austin Peterson for 11 yards to the WARTBURG0, 1ST DOWN MC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:19, Alex Tanney pass attempt to Stefan Flynn good. |
| | | Wartburg College 35, Monmouth College 28 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 64 yards, TOP 01:17 |
| | | Matt Batton kickoff 11 yards to the MC41, on-side kick, recovered by WARTBURG on MC41. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc41 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 00:19. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Mc41 | Dan Stiefel rush for no gain to the MC41. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Wartburg College 35, Monmouth College 28 |