| | | Simpson won the toss, deferred. Wartburg will receive. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg35 | WARTBURG ball on WARTBURG35. |
| | | Reed Pedersen kickoff 53 yards to the SIM12, Brad Vogel return 28 yards to the SIM40 (Matt Kastli). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim40 | Taylor Nelson rush for 1 yard to the SIM41 (Spencer Capitan). |
| Sim | 2-9 | at Sim41 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 3 yards to the SIM44 (Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 3-6 | at Sim44 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Billy Weathers. |
| Sim | 4-6 | at Sim44 | Logan Klein punt 40 yards to the WARTBURG16, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 01:23 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg16 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 13:37. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg16 | Reese Thompson rush for 39 yards to the SIM45, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Johnnie Sims;Tyler Craig). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim45 | Logan Schrader sacked for loss of 1 yard to the SIM46 (Johnnie Sims;Mike Munson). |
| Wartburg | 2-11 | at Sim46 | Reese Thompson rush for 3 yards to the SIM43 (Grant Focht). |
| Wartburg | 3-8 | at Sim43 | Logan Schrader pass incomplete to Donald Miller, dropped pass. |
| Wartburg | 4-8 | at Sim43 | Grant Zimmerman punt 30 yards to the SIM13, fair catch by Mike Kuhn. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 41 yards, TOP 01:52 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim13 | SIMPSON drive start at 11:45. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim13 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Brad Vogel for 3 yards to the SIM16 (Garrett McGrane). |
| Sim | 2-7 | at Sim16 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 9 yards to the SIM25, 1ST DOWN SIM (Garrett McGrane). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim25 | Michael Chia rush for 4 yards to the SIM29 (Ben Bentil;Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 2-6 | at Sim29 | Michael Chia rush for loss of 1 yard to the SIM28 (Ryan Billings;Spencer Capitan). |
| Sim | 3-7 | at Sim28 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Michael Chia for 28 yards to the WARTBURG44 (Ryan Billings), PENALTY SIM personal foul (Cameron Lewelle) 14 yards to the SIM14, NO PLAY. |
| Sim | 3-21 | at Sim14 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Mike Kuhn for 6 yards to the SIM20 (Garrett McGrane). |
| Sim | 4-15 | at Sim20 | Logan Klein punt 44 yards to the WARTBURG36, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 7 yards, TOP 03:28 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg36 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 08:17. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg36 | Logan Schrader rush for 2 yards to the WARTBURG38 (TJ Alger). |
| Wartburg | 2-8 | at Wartburg38 | Connor Dahlstro rush for 4 yards to the WARTBURG42 (Grant Focht). |
| Wartburg | 3-4 | at Wartburg42 | Connor Dahlstro rush for 1 yard to the WARTBURG43 (Grant Focht;Clay Finley). |
| Wartburg | 4-3 | at Wartburg43 | Grant Zimmerman punt 15 yards to the SIM42, downed (blocked by TEAM). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 01:49 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim42 | SIMPSON drive start at 06:28. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim42 | Michael Chia rush for loss of 4 yards to the SIM38 (Ryan Billings). |
| Sim | 2-14 | at Sim38 | Taylor Nelson sacked for loss of 4 yards to the SIM34 (Martin Hyatte). |
| Sim | 3-18 | at Sim34 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Michael Chia for 8 yards to the SIM42 (Ben Bentil). |
| Sim | 4-10 | at Sim42 | Logan Klein punt 43 yards to the WARTBURG15, fair catch by Logan Schrader, PENALTY SIM illegal procedure 5 yards to the SIM37, NO PLAY. |
| Sim | 4-15 | at Sim37 | Logan Klein punt 36 yards to the WARTBURG27, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 5 yards, TOP 02:22 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg27 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 04:06. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg27 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Cywettnie Brown for 33 yards to the SIM40, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Blake Heitmeier). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim40 | Brandon Domeyer rush for 26 yards to the SIM14, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Grant Focht). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim14 | Reese Thompson rush for loss of 1 yard to the SIM15 (Taylor Stockdal). |
| Wartburg | 2-11 | at Sim15 | Reese Thompson rush for 9 yards to the SIM6 (Mike Munson). |
| Wartburg | 3-2 | at Sim06 | Reese Thompson rush for 1 yard to the SIM5 (Tyler Craig). |
| Wartburg | 4-1 | at Sim05 | Reese Thompson rush for 1 yard to the SIM4, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Mike Munson;Kevin Hughes). |
| Wartburg | 1-G | at Sim04 | Reese Thompson rush for 2 yards to the SIM2 (Johnnie Sims). |
| Wartburg | 2-G | at Sim02 | Reese Thompson rush for 2 yards to the SIM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:02. |
| | | Frank Loconti kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by TEAM). |
| | | Wartburg College 6, Simpson 0 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 73 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Reed Pedersen kickoff 53 yards to the SIM12, Mitch Overland return 30 yards to the SIM42 (Ryan Billings). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim42 | SIMPSON drive start at 15:00. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim42 | PENALTY WARTBURG personal foul 14 yards to the WARTBURG44, 1ST DOWN SIM. |
| | | Wartburg College 6, Simpson 0 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg44 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg44 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Brad Vogel. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Wartburg44 | Michael Chia rush for 1 yard to the WARTBURG43 (Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 3-9 | at Wartburg43 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Brad Vogel for 12 yards to the WARTBURG31, 1ST DOWN SIM (Garrett McGrane). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg31 | PENALTY SIM false start (Danny Kelley) 5 yards to the WARTBURG36. |
| Sim | 1-15 | at Wartburg36 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Tyler Kenny for no gain to the WARTBURG36 (Spencer Capitan;Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 2-15 | at Wartburg36 | Taylor Nelson rush for 3 yards to the WARTBURG33 (Ryan Billings). |
| Sim | 3-12 | at Wartburg33 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Mike Kuhn (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 4-12 | at Wartburg33 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Mike Kuhn. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 25 yards, TOP 17:52 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg33 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 12:08. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg33 | Logan Schrader sacked for loss of 6 yards to the WARTBURG27 (Johnnie Sims). |
| Wartburg | 2-16 | at Wartburg27 | Logan Schrader rush for 9 yards to the WARTBURG36 (Taylor Stockdal). |
| Wartburg | 3-7 | at Wartburg36 | PENALTY WARTBURG false start (Brandon Domeyer) 5 yards to the WARTBURG31. |
| Wartburg | 3-12 | at Wartburg31 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Dj Looft for 17 yards to the WARTBURG48, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Corey Sterling). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg48 | Logan Schrader rush for 10 yards to the SIM42, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Corey Sterling). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim42 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Connor Dahlstro for 2 yards to the SIM40 (Mark Cronin). |
| Wartburg | 2-8 | at Sim40 | Connor Dahlstro rush for loss of 4 yards to the SIM44, fumble by Connor Dahlstro recovered by WARTBURG Connor Dahlstro at SIM44, Connor Dahlstro for 3 yards to the SIM41 (Sean Degoey). |
| Wartburg | 3-9 | at Sim41 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Dj Looft for 11 yards to the SIM30, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (TJ Alger). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim30 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Cywettnie Brown for 30 yards to the SIM0, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:45. |
| | | Frank Loconti kick attempt good. |
| | | Wartburg College 13, Simpson 0 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 67 yards, TOP 04:24 |
| | | Reed Pedersen kickoff 34 yards to the SIM31, Brad Vogel return 0 yards to the SIM31. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim31 | SIMPSON drive start at 07:44. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim31 | PENALTY SIM false start (Jay Hackett) 5 yards to the SIM26. |
| Sim | 1-15 | at Sim26 | Taylor Nelson rush for loss of 2 yards to the SIM24 (Martin Hyatte). |
| Sim | 2-17 | at Sim24 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Brad Vogel for 76 yards to the WARTBURG0, 1ST DOWN SIM, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:52. |
| | | Logan Klein kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by David Hoehne). |
| | | Wartburg College 13, Simpson 6 |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 69 yards, TOP 00:52 |
| | | Logan Klein kickoff 65 yards to the WARTBURG0, touchback. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg25 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 06:52. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg25 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Dj Looft for 27 yards to the SIM48, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (TJ Alger). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim48 | Logan Schrader sacked for loss of 8 yards to the WARTBURG44 (Aaron Gaynor). |
| Wartburg | 2-18 | at Wartburg44 | Reese Thompson rush for 5 yards to the WARTBURG49 (Mark Cronin). |
| Wartburg | 3-13 | at Wartburg49 | Logan Schrader pass incomplete to Dj Looft (Grant Focht). |
| Wartburg | 4-13 | at Wartburg49 | Grant Zimmerman punt 23 yards to the SIM28, fair catch by Mike Kuhn. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 24 yards, TOP 02:03 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim28 | SIMPSON drive start at 04:49. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim28 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Michael Chia for 2 yards to the SIM30 (Ryan Billings). |
| Sim | 2-8 | at Sim30 | Michael Chia rush for loss of 3 yards to the SIM27 (Mark Lueschow;Ryan Billings). |
| Sim | 3-11 | at Sim27 | Taylor Nelson pass intercepted by Ryan Billings at the SIM31, Ryan Billings return 20 yards to the SIM11 (Michael Chia). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:33 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim11 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 03:16. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim11 | PENALTY WARTBURG false start (Chris Brinkmeie) 5 yards to the SIM16. |
| Wartburg | 1-15 | at Sim16 | Connor Dahlstro rush for 5 yards to the SIM11 (Grant Focht;Tyler Craig). |
| Wartburg | 2-10 | at Sim11 | Logan Schrader sacked for loss of 4 yards to the SIM15 (Scott Vierow). |
| Wartburg | 3-14 | at Sim15 | Timeout Simpson, clock 01:56. |
| Wartburg | 3-14 | at Sim15 | Logan Schrader pass incomplete to Cywettnie Brown (Mark Cronin). |
| Wartburg | 4-14 | at Sim15 | Frank Loconti field goal attempt from 32 BLOCKED, recovered by SIM TEAM at SIM12 spot at SIM12, clock 01:45 (blocked by Mark Cronin), TEAM for 9 yards to the SIM21. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 03:16 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim21 | Michael Chia rush for no gain to the SIM21 (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim21 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Brad Vogel for 2 yards to the SIM23, out-of-bounds. |
| Sim | 3-8 | at Sim23 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Billy Weathers for 12 yards to the SIM35, 1ST DOWN SIM (Garrett McGrane). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim35 | Taylor Nelson sacked for loss of 6 yards to the SIM29 (Chad Crawford). |
| Sim | 2-16 | at Sim29 | Taylor Nelson rush for 6 yards to the SIM35, out-of-bounds. |
| Sim | 3-10 | at Sim35 | Timeout Simpson, clock 00:13. |
| Sim | 3-10 | at Sim35 | Michael Chia rush for 2 yards to the SIM37 (Ryan Billings). |
| Sim | 4-8 | at Sim37 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 16 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Wartburg College 13, Simpson 6 |
| Sim | 4-8 | at Sim37 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, SIM ball on SIM35. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 16 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Logan Klein kickoff 62 yards to the WARTBURG3, out-of-bounds, WARTBURG ball on WARTBURG35. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg35 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 15:00. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg35 | Logan Schrader rush for 13 yards to the WARTBURG48, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Mark Cronin). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg48 | Reese Thompson rush for loss of 5 yards to the WARTBURG43 (David Adams). |
| Wartburg | 2-15 | at Wartburg43 | Logan Schrader rush for loss of 2 yards to the WARTBURG41, fumble by Logan Schrader recovered by SIM David Adams at WARTBURG41. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:26 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg41 | SIMPSON drive start at 13:34. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg41 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Brad Vogel (Riley Anderson), QB hurry by Martin Hyatte. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Wartburg41 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Michael Chia for 12 yards to the WARTBURG29, 1ST DOWN SIM (Riley Anderson;Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg29 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Michael Chia for 11 yards to the WARTBURG18, 1ST DOWN SIM (Riley Anderson). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg18 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Taylor Rogers. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Wartburg18 | Taylor Nelson rush for 3 yards to the WARTBURG15 (Martin Hyatte). |
| Sim | 3-7 | at Wartburg15 | PENALTY SIM false start (Michael Chia) 5 yards to the WARTBURG20. |
| Sim | 3-12 | at Wartburg20 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Alex McCarty. |
| Sim | 4-12 | at Wartburg20 | Logan Klein field goal attempt from 37 MISSED - wide left, spot at WARTBURG20, clock 11:10. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 21 yards, TOP 02:24 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg20 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 11:10. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg20 | Reese Thompson rush for 5 yards to the WARTBURG25 (Tyler Craig). |
| Wartburg | 2-5 | at Wartburg25 | Logan Schrader rush for 3 yards to the WARTBURG28, out-of-bounds (DJ Bennett). |
| Wartburg | 3-2 | at Wartburg28 | Brandon Domeyer rush for 1 yard to the WARTBURG29 (Ted Haag). |
| Wartburg | 4-1 | at Wartburg29 | Timeout Simpson, clock 09:45. |
| Wartburg | 4-1 | at Wartburg29 | Grant Zimmerman punt 40 yards to the SIM31, fair catch by Mike Kuhn. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:32 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim31 | SIMPSON drive start at 09:38. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim31 | Michael Chia rush for no gain to the SIM31 (Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim31 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 13 yards to the SIM44, 1ST DOWN SIM (Spencer Capitan;Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim44 | Taylor Nelson pass intercepted by Riley Anderson at the WARTBURG26, Riley Anderson return 0 yards to the WARTBURG26 (Brad Vogel). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 13 yards, TOP 01:10 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg26 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 08:28. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg26 | Logan Schrader sacked for loss of 1 yard to the WARTBURG25 (David Adams). |
| Wartburg | 2-11 | at Wartburg25 | Brandon Domeyer rush for 4 yards to the WARTBURG29 (Tyler Craig;DJ Bennett). |
| Wartburg | 3-7 | at Wartburg29 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Cywettnie Brown for 16 yards to the WARTBURG45, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Sean Degoey). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg45 | Reese Thompson rush for loss of 1 yard to the WARTBURG44 (Kevin Hughes). |
| Wartburg | 2-11 | at Wartburg44 | Reese Thompson rush for 9 yards to the SIM47 (Mark Cronin). |
| Wartburg | 3-2 | at Sim47 | Logan Schrader pass incomplete to Donald Miller. |
| Wartburg | 4-2 | at Sim47 | Grant Zimmerman punt 47 yards to the SIM0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 27 yards, TOP 03:21 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim25 | SIM ball on SIM20. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim20 | SIMPSON drive start at 05:07. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim20 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Brad Vogel for 42 yards to the WARTBURG38, 1ST DOWN SIM (Riley Anderson). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg38 | Michael Chia rush for loss of 3 yards to the WARTBURG41 (Chad Crawford;Joey Naig). |
| Sim | 2-13 | at Wartburg41 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Alex McCarty for 2 yards to the WARTBURG39 (Garrett McGrane). |
| Sim | 3-11 | at Wartburg39 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Taylor Rogers. |
| Sim | 4-11 | at Wartburg39 | PENALTY SIM delay of game 5 yards to the WARTBURG44. |
| Sim | 4-16 | at Wartburg44 | Logan Klein punt 31 yards to the WARTBURG13, fair catch by Spencer Capitan. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 36 yards, TOP 02:12 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg13 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 02:55. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg13 | Connor Dahlstro rush for 20 yards to the WARTBURG33, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Tyler Craig). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg33 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Dj Looft for 12 yards to the WARTBURG45, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Tyler Craig). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg45 | Logan Schrader rush for 4 yards to the WARTBURG49 (Scott Vierow). |
| Wartburg | 2-6 | at Wartburg49 | Connor Dahlstro rush for 5 yards to the SIM46 (DJ Bennett). |
| Wartburg | 3-1 | at Sim46 | Connor Dahlstro rush for loss of 1 yard to the SIM47 (Tyler Craig). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 40 yards, TOP 03:02 |
| | | Wartburg College 13, Simpson 6 |
| Wartburg | 4-2 | at Sim47 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wartburg | 4-2 | at Sim47 | Grant Zimmerman punt 31 yards to the SIM16, fair catch by Mike Kuhn. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 40 yards, TOP 03:02 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim16 | SIMPSON drive start at 14:53. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim16 | Brad Vogel rush for loss of 1 yard to the SIM15 (Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 2-11 | at Sim15 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Brad Vogel. |
| Sim | 3-11 | at Sim15 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 15 yards to the SIM30, 1ST DOWN SIM (Spencer Capitan). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim30 | Michael Chia rush for 5 yards to the SIM35 (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 2-5 | at Sim35 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Alex McCarty for 10 yards to the SIM45, 1ST DOWN SIM (Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim45 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Brad Vogel. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim45 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Mike Kuhn. |
| Sim | 3-10 | at Sim45 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 14 yards to the WARTBURG41, 1ST DOWN SIM (Riley Anderson). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg41 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Billy Weathers, PENALTY SIM holding (Michael Chia) 10 yards to the SIM49, NO PLAY. |
| Sim | 1-20 | at Sim49 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Walker Holland for 7 yards to the WARTBURG44. |
| Sim | 2-13 | at Wartburg44 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Ryan Olson for 12 yards to the WARTBURG32 (Joey Naig;Riley Anderson). |
| Sim | 3-1 | at Wartburg32 | Taylor Nelson rush for 2 yards to the WARTBURG30, 1ST DOWN SIM (Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg30 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Billy Weathers, dropped pass. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Wartburg30 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Brad Vogel for 19 yards to the WARTBURG11, 1ST DOWN SIM (Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg11 | Michael Chia rush for loss of 1 yard to the WARTBURG12 (Ross Naylor). |
| Sim | 2-11 | at Wartburg12 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 7 yards to the WARTBURG5 (Riley Anderson;Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 3-4 | at Wartburg05 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Taylor Rogers. |
| Sim | 4-4 | at Wartburg05 | Taylor Nelson pass intercepted by Ryan Billings at the WARTBURG0, Ryan Billings return 0 yards to the WARTBURG0 (Taylor Rogers), touchback. |
| | | Drive: 17 plays, 79 yards, TOP 07:07 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg25 | WARTBURG ball on WARTBURG20. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg20 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 07:46. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg20 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Dj Looft for 9 yards to the WARTBURG29 (Brandon Abernat). |
| Wartburg | 2-1 | at Wartburg29 | Connor Dahlstro rush for loss of 1 yard to the WARTBURG28 (Ben Borland). |
| Wartburg | 3-2 | at Wartburg28 | Logan Schrader sacked for loss of 8 yards to the WARTBURG20 (Mark Cronin). |
| Wartburg | 4-10 | at Wartburg20 | Grant Zimmerman punt 49 yards to the SIM31, fair catch by Mike Kuhn. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 02:01 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim31 | SIMPSON drive start at 05:45. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim31 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Brad Vogel for 48 yards to the WARTBURG21, 1ST DOWN SIM (Riley Anderson). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg21 | PENALTY SIM false start (Danny Kelley) 5 yards to the WARTBURG26. |
| Sim | 1-15 | at Wartburg26 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Michael Chia for 5 yards to the WARTBURG21 (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Wartburg21 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Taylor Rogers. |
| Sim | 3-10 | at Wartburg21 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Michael Chia. |
| Sim | 4-10 | at Wartburg21 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 21 yards to the WARTBURG0, 1ST DOWN SIM, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:24. |
| | | Logan Klein kick attempt good. |
| | | Wartburg College 13, Simpson 13 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 69 yards, TOP 01:21 |
| | | Logan Klein kickoff 65 yards to the WARTBURG0, touchback. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg25 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 04:24. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg25 | Reese Thompson rush for 16 yards to the WARTBURG41, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Grant Focht). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg41 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Logan Ruffridge for 13 yards to the SIM46, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Adam Bobier). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim46 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Donald Miller for 3 yards to the SIM43 (Ted Haag). |
| Wartburg | 2-7 | at Sim43 | Logan Schrader pass intercepted by TJ Alger at the SIM29, TJ Alger return 3 yards to the SIM32 (Curt Hruska). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 32 yards, TOP 01:33 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim32 | SIMPSON drive start at 02:51. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim32 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Brad Vogel. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim32 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Billy Weathers (Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 3-10 | at Sim32 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 11 yards to the SIM43, 1ST DOWN SIM (Spencer Capitan). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim43 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Taylor Rogers. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim43 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Ryan Olson, dropped pass. |
| Sim | 3-10 | at Sim43 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Ryan Olson for 14 yards to the WARTBURG43, 1ST DOWN SIM (Riley Anderson). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Wartburg43 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 43 yards to the WARTBURG0, 1ST DOWN SIM, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:42. |
| | | Logan Klein kick attempt good. |
| | | Simpson 20, Wartburg College 13 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 68 yards, TOP 01:13 |
| | | Logan Klein kickoff 57 yards to the WARTBURG8, Cywettnie Brown return 9 yards to the WARTBURG17 (Sean Degoey). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg17 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 01:38. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg17 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Cywettnie Brown for 40 yards to the SIM43, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Mark Cronin). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim43 | Logan Schrader pass incomplete to Curt Hruska. |
| Wartburg | 2-10 | at Sim43 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Donald Miller for 5 yards to the SIM38 (Grant Focht), QB hurry by Johnnie Sims. |
| Wartburg | 3-5 | at Sim38 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Curt Hruska for 13 yards to the SIM25, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Corey Sterling). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim25 | Logan Schrader rush for 4 yards to the SIM21, out-of-bounds (DJ Bennett). |
| Wartburg | 2-6 | at Sim21 | Timeout Simpson, clock 00:57. |
| Wartburg | 2-6 | at Sim21 | Logan Schrader pass incomplete to Reese Thompson (Aaron Gaynor). |
| Wartburg | 3-6 | at Sim21 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Curt Hruska for 16 yards to the SIM5, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Grant Focht). |
| Wartburg | 1-G | at Sim05 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Donald Miller for 5 yards to the SIM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:37. |
| Wartburg | 1-G | at Sim03 | Timeout Simpson, clock 00:37. |
| | | Frank Loconti kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Ben Borland). |
| | | Simpson 20, Wartburg College 19 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 83 yards, TOP 01:03 |
| | | Frank Loconti kickoff 15 yards to the 50 yardline, on-side kick, recovered by SIM on 50 yardline. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim50 | SIMPSON drive start at 00:35. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim50 | TEAM rush for loss of 4 yards to the SIM46. |
| Sim | 2-14 | at Sim46 | Timeout Wartburg College, clock 00:32. |
| Sim | 2-14 | at Sim46 | Taylor Nelson rush for loss of 10 yards to the SIM36 (Ben Bentil). |
| Sim | 3-24 | at Sim36 | Timeout Wartburg College, clock 00:28. |
| Sim | 3-24 | at Sim36 | Michael Chia rush for loss of 2 yards to the SIM34 (Garrett McGrane). |
| Sim | 4-26 | at Sim34 | Timeout Wartburg College, clock 00:22. |
| Sim | 4-26 | at Sim34 | Logan Klein punt 38 yards to the WARTBURG28, Spencer Capitan return 13 yards to the WARTBURG41 (Ryan Deatrick). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 16 yards, TOP 00:20 |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg41 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 00:15. |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Wartburg41 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Dj Looft for 7 yards to the WARTBURG48 (TJ Alger). |
| Wartburg | 2-3 | at Wartburg48 | Logan Schrader pass complete to Cywettnie Brown for 24 yards to the SIM28, Logan Ruffridge for 12 yards to the SIM16, 1ST DOWN WARTBURG (Grant Focht). |
| Wartburg | 1-10 | at Sim16 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 43 yards, TOP 00:15 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Simpson 20, Wartburg College 19 |